The day after tomorrow, I am flying to Amsterdam (and then to Turkey), and I remembered that I had an unanswered question to myself about how baggage scanners work at the airport. Of course, I knew that it was essentially computer tomography, X-rays and all that, but I wanted more details. And below is the response as to why they ask you to take out water, and why sometimes they do not.
It turns out that modern scanners can not only see the shape of objects but also determine what material they are made of. How does a regular scanner work? Dense materials (such as metal) absorb a lot of radiation and appear bright or opaque in images. Less dense materials absorb little radiation and appear dark. Hence laptops, for example, had to be taken out — not because the scanner couldn’t recognize them, but because their dense components (battery, boards) could be used to hide other prohibited items behind them. So, it has long been not just scanners, but computer tomography — in essence, the bag or suitcase is scanned from all sides, then a 3D image is created. It seems like everyone knows this.
But I mentioned that they understand the materials items are made from. How?
It turns out that the scanner uses dual-energy X-ray technology. It scans the object with two beams of rays of different energy levels (high and low). Since materials absorb radiation differently depending on the energy of the ray and their atomic composition, the system analyzes this difference. Based on the absorption ratio of the two beams, the effective atomic number Z — a key characteristic, a kind of “elemental fingerprint” of the substance, is calculated.
The problem is that this “fingerprint” of water (~7.4) and many explosives are almost identical. This is precisely why water was banned. Relying only on this parameter would mean receiving a huge number of false alarms.
Here is where computer tomography (CT) comes into play. The scanner creates an accurate three-dimensional (3D) model of the contents of the bag. From the 3D model, the system obtains the exact volume (V) of each object. Based on data on the absorption of X-rays, its mass (m) is calculated. Then it’s simple: ρ=m/V.
That is, the system does not make a decision based on one parameter. It plots each detected substance on a two-dimensional graph with axes “Z — density.” On this graph, water and explosives, having almost the same atomic number, occupy completely different positions due to different densities.
And that’s precisely why water can sometimes be carried through. Smart machines simply do not mark it as something significant, but still identify it as water. Then procedures follow. If the airport has updated the machines, but not the procedures, they will ask to dispose of the water. But also, not all machines are updated everywhere, and at the same airport, it depends on which line is open at the moment.
The cost of such a scanner is $300-400 thousand.
The scanners for people work differently. They use millimeter waves. They pass through clothing and reflect back from the skin. Water absorbs them significantly, so they penetrate only a couple of millimeters. The system registers the reflected signal and constructs a three-dimensional map of the body surface and objects under the clothing. But it does not show this — instead, it displays a simplified contour of a person and shows on it what ML found unusual. Therefore, by the way, many try to carry various items inside themselves, knowing that such a scanner absolutely cannot see it.
Hi, I'm Rauf Aliev. 